Best Hoagies and Sandwiches on LBI

Catering for Small and Large Gatherings

Take-Out Gourmet Italian Dishes

Specializing In

Welcome to THE Mario's Italian Market of Surf City, New Jersey.  We're proud to serve the Long Beach Island community for over 26 years with the very best Italian deli, baked goods and catering this side of Brooklyn. Your satisfaction means everything to us and that's why we pay attention to all the details, small and large. From our fresh daily made mozzarella and baked goods to our scrumptuous pasta side dishes and sandwiches, it doesn't matter if it's a single sandwich or catering for a large gathering, you and your family will always be delighted with everything you purchase.

• Full Line Bakery • Hoagies & Sandwiches

• Complete Gourmet Catering Service  

• Fresh Mozzarella • Assorted Cheeses

• Boars Head Cold Cuts • Olive Bar  

Freshly Made Pasta and Veggie Dishes

• Our own sauces and side dishes

• Now carrying quality steak and sausage

(2 day order in advance)

About Us

Join the Mario's Family

* indicates required

Sign up for our email list and stay up to the minute with Mario's specials, promotions and news. We don't share our list and you can opt-out anytime. Come join the Mario's Family!

Join the Mario's Family

We Feature

1905 Long Beach Blvd.

Surf City, NJ 08008

open 6 days a week

Closed Tuesday

9 am to 6 pm



Always call ahead

for best service

Featured Items

Thanks to Cultinary Road Trip for this video tour of Mario's. Check it out!

Call ahead to ensure what you see is not sold out

You can now have Mario's hoagies, hot subs and salads delivered right to your door. Delivery hours: 10 am - 5 pm daily

Click here to see delivery menu and for delivery

Please Note: We ONLY deliver items from our delivery menu

Catering and other dishes may be excluded from delivery

Click here for specials. Must order by Monday July 1.

Make your 4th a Smash Success with our Holiday Specials